Substitutions

Cream Cheese Substitutes

From Your Fridgeschedule7 min read
Cream Cheese Substitutes

Mascarpone is the closest cream cheese substitute: use it in the same amount, 1 to 1, in almost any recipe. It is richer and a little less tangy than cream cheese, with the same smooth, spreadable texture, so it works in frosting, cheesecake, dips, and spreads without any other changes.

Cream cheese shows up in so many places — bagels, cheesecake, frosting, pasta sauce, dips — that the right substitute depends on what you are making. This guide covers the best swaps one by one, with exact ratios and an honest note on where each one falls short, plus a quick pick-by-use guide at the end.

Mascarpone: the closest swap, 1 to 1

Mascarpone is an Italian soft cheese made from cream, and it is the nearest thing to cream cheese in both texture and behavior. Use it in a straight 1 to 1 swap: 8 ounces of mascarpone for 8 ounces of cream cheese, with no other changes to the recipe.

It is richer and less tangy than cream cheese, which is a plus in cheesecake and frosting, where it tastes smooth and buttery. In a dip or a savory spread, you may miss the tang; add a squeeze of lemon juice or a spoonful of sour cream to bring it back.

Mascarpone is softer than block cream cheese, so chill anything frosted with it before serving, and keep it cold until you need it. It costs more than cream cheese and usually comes in smaller tubs, so check the weight on the tub and buy enough.

Neufchâtel: 1 to 1, with less fat

Neufchâtel is the easiest substitute to use, because it is made almost exactly like cream cheese but with about a third less fat. Swap it 1 to 1 in any recipe, and treat it the same way: soften it at room temperature before beating, and bake it the same as cream cheese.

The lower fat means a slightly softer set in cheesecake and a frosting that is a touch less firm, but the difference is small and most people won't notice it. It spreads well on bagels and crackers straight from the tub.

Look for it in block form next to the cream cheese. If your store only stocks whipped Neufchâtel, it still works in dips and spreads, but weigh it rather than measuring by volume, since the whipped tubs are mostly air.

Blended cottage cheese: 1 to 1, after blending

Plain cottage cheese can stand in for cream cheese once it is blended smooth. Put it in a food processor or blender and run it for 1 to 2 minutes, scraping down the sides, until it is completely smooth with no curds left. Then use it 1 to 1 for cream cheese.

Blending matters: unblended cottage cheese stays lumpy and will show in frosting or cheesecake. For a richer result, blend in 2 tablespoons of butter or heavy cream per cup of cottage cheese; that brings the fat closer to cream cheese and makes the texture silkier.

This swap works best in cooked dishes, dips, and cheesecake, where the mild flavor disappears into the recipe. For frosting, it is workable but less tangy than real cream cheese, so add a teaspoon of lemon juice per cup to sharpen it.

Greek yogurt: great for dips, not for cheesecake

Plain Greek yogurt is a good substitute when the cream cheese is going into a dip, a sauce, or a dressing, where its tang is welcome. Use full-fat Greek yogurt in a 1 to 1 swap, and stir it in at the end of cooking rather than boiling it, since it can split at high heat.

For a thicker result that behaves more like cream cheese, strain the yogurt first: line a sieve with a coffee filter or cheesecloth, add the yogurt, and let it drain in the fridge for 2 to 3 hours. You will lose about a third of the volume as whey, so start with a third more than you need.

Don't use Greek yogurt on its own in cheesecake or frosting. It is too thin and too tangy, and a cheesecake made with it often won't set. It works in frosting only as a partial swap: replace up to half the cream cheese with yogurt and keep the rest as mascarpone or Neufchâtel.

Ricotta: drain it first, best in cooked dishes

Whole-milk ricotta can replace cream cheese in cooked dishes and some baked ones, but it needs a little help. It is grainier and wetter than cream cheese, so drain it first: put it in a fine sieve over a bowl for 30 minutes, then use it 1 to 1.

Drained ricotta works well in pasta sauces, stuffed pasta, and savory bakes, where its mild flavor fits and the texture melts into the dish. In cheesecake it gives a lighter, more delicate set, closer to an Italian-style cheesecake, which some people prefer.

Skip ricotta for frosting and for spreading on a bagel. Even drained, it stays slightly grainy and too soft to hold a frosting shape, and it doesn't have the tang that makes cream cheese frosting taste like itself.

Dairy-free: cashew cream and dairy-free spreads

If you need a dairy-free option, soaked cashews blended smooth make a good homemade cream cheese. Soak 1 cup of raw cashews in hot water for 30 minutes, drain, then blend with 2 tablespoons lemon juice, 2 tablespoons water, and 1/2 teaspoon salt until completely smooth, about 2 to 3 minutes. Use it 1 to 1 for spreads and dips.

Store-bought dairy-free cream cheese is the simplest option and is made to behave like the real thing in most recipes. Check the label: some brands are almond-based, some soy-based, and a few don't melt well, so pick one marked for cooking if it is going into a baked dish.

For frosting, a dairy-free cream cheese spread usually works 1 to 1, but it can be softer than dairy cream cheese, so chill the frosted cake and add a little extra powdered sugar if the frosting looks loose.

Which substitute should I use?

For cheesecake, use mascarpone or blended cottage cheese. Both set firmly and taste close to the original. Neufchâtel is a fine third choice, though the set will be slightly softer.

For frosting, mascarpone is the best pick, with blended cottage cheese as a budget option. Keep the frosting cold and chill the finished cake before slicing.

For dips and spreads, almost any swap works: Greek yogurt, blended cottage cheese, ricotta, or dairy-free spreads. Pick the one you have, and adjust the tang with lemon juice.

For pasta sauce and other cooked dishes, use Neufchâtel, ricotta, or mascarpone. All three melt smoothly into a hot sauce. Stir Greek yogurt in off the heat so it doesn't split.

For a bagel, Neufchâtel is the closest in taste and texture, and mascarpone is the richest. Greek yogurt works in a pinch, but it is thinner and sharper than a proper spread.

Frequently asked

Can I substitute cream cheese in cheesecake?expand_more

For cheesecake, use mascarpone or blended cottage cheese, not yogurt or sour cream on their own. Yogurt and sour cream are too thin and too tangy, and a cheesecake made with them often won't set firmly.

What is the best substitute for cream cheese frosting?expand_more

Mascarpone makes the smoothest frosting, though it is softer than cream cheese, so chill the frosted cake. Blended cottage cheese with a little butter also works, but it tastes milder and less tangy than a classic cream cheese frosting.

Is Neufchâtel the same as cream cheese?expand_more

Yes. Neufchâtel is made the same way as cream cheese but with about a third less fat, and it spreads and bakes almost identically. It is the simplest swap if your store stocks it.

Can I use a dairy-free substitute?expand_more

Yes, and it is often the best choice. Dairy-free cream cheese spreads are made to behave like the real thing, and soaked cashews blended with lemon juice and salt make a good homemade version for dips and spreads.

Does low-fat cream cheese work the same in recipes?expand_more

No. Low-fat cream cheese is a lighter version of the same product, and it behaves the same in almost every recipe. The main difference is a slightly softer set in cheesecake and frosting.

cream cheesesubstitutesbakingfrostingcheesecakedairy-free